Slipping Closer to the Edge…
These writings are from about a month before my daughter Elizabeth Blue died. She was at home and needing 24 hour care, having had a stroke following unsuccessful surgery and chemo to remove the cancer that had spread to her brain. She was in a peaceful state of grace that is hard to capture in words and images.
August 24, 2012: a group email
dear ones,
again, I’m not sure how long it’s been since writing, but when I start to receive texts and emails asking what is going on, I can feel it’s time to share more outside of this small and yet expansive, world I’m living in.
Day to day, it’s hard to see change, much like when you have a newborn baby, and can’t see how quickly she is changing because you’re so immersed. But when I look at photos of Elizabeth now, I can see that her head is more swollen, and I know she now has a bump on the back of her neck that is very likely another tumor, or one that has spread, so there is evidence that the cancer is growing. She has also had several episodes of muscle tremors, with her heart racing, which is uncomfortable for her, but responds to muscle-relaxants. It is likely a sign of neurological symptoms from the tumor, and may indicate other symptoms to come.
Some days she seems even less able to track things in a linear way, but this seems so natural now it’s hard to notice the change. Today also for the first time she said her mind was busy when I asked (rather than quiet), using her hands to show me “chatty”. She often uses her hands to communicate, though she is able to speak. She has said she is “doing work”, working through some things internally on this journey that need to be completed. She is aware of the support she has, from all of us, in addition to the unseen forces.
There have been many visitors, (including the nurse and nurse’s aide 2 times a week), which she seems to enjoy though gets tired quickly. She says yes to everyone who has asked to visit, though I limit the schedule so she (and I) aren’t too tired. Often I am happiest when I have time alone to just sit with Elizabeth, like the other morning when I played Coleman Barks’ album, his readings of Rumi poetry, and we listened together, which was a beautiful way to start our day. The physical tasks of feeding, changing, turning her, giving medicines at the right time, etc, often take up most of the time in the day, but I try to find times still when we can simply sit and be…
We have fewer people here, which is easier in some ways, harder in others. Tashe and Terri (my sister and sister-in-law) were here which was immensely helpful. My mom is leaving this weekend, and it’s been wonderful to have her. She’s been patient and generous with me, even when I’m not at my best, not as patient and loving as I’d like to be. Julianna (my younger daughter, 19 years old) heads back to NYU on Tuesday, and I’m going to miss her terribly. She’s been home all summer, the longest time we’ve had together in many years and I’ve enjoyed every day with her. During this difficult time she’s been just amazing – so loving, supportive, thoughtful, helpful, generous and just beautiful to be with. She is ready to go back to school, and though I can’t imagine how I could function in that world now, I can see that it will be a good place for her right now.
So next week it will be just Zelie (my partner), Elizabeth and me here, and we’ll see how that goes. Zelie is wonderful – patient and loving, and really sweet to see the two of them together. Greg (Elizabeth’s father) continues to come every week from Friday to Sunday, and brings Elizabeth treats from Berkeley and good company as he sits with her for hours each day, and he just cooked us all a wonderful dinner. We may call on friends and hospice volunteers more, taking up offers of meals and perhaps just to come and sit with Elizabeth so we can do errands or have some time for emails and maybe even some breaks…
It doesn’t feel like Elizabeth’s ready to leave us yet, and yet we are aware it could happen at any time. Most days it simply feels like I’m caring for her while she’s very ill, disabled, but really hard to see/believe that she’s dying. The hardest day for me so far was going to Elizabeth’s apartment for the first time without her, and seeing all her belongings: her artwork, clothes, lists of things to do, all the outward ordinary objects that connect me to her in her previous self, all the ways we spent time together, the gifts I bought her, the stories of getting these shoes in Seattle, or that friend who made her that drawing, etc…it was just heartbreaking. Then a couple of days later I went back, and already it had shifted, and was much easier…so time continues to help, and continuing to be present to whatever degree possible.
I’ve been in the process of writing this in bits for days, as that’s how life is right now, and this feels broken up and unsatisfying, as some of the days do. There’s an unsettled quality right now, and also an immense amount of love and gratitude in each day. Grateful for all that has been and all that is.
love and gratitude to you all,
Lucia
We managed to take Elizabeth outside in a reclining wheelchair to the backyard last week, which she’d really wanted to do:



August 28, 2012 – from Lucia’s Journal
Tonight I had the thought to tell Elizabeth that I would willingly trade places with her, sacrifice my life for hers, and then I realized how arrogant that was, the idea that my life was better then hers, my situation, my potential future, better than hers. I saw in that instant that her life and situation, however long, has nothing wrong with it, nothing that she needs to “trade” for. I shared this all with her, and she agreed, nodding. I finished by saying that I wanted her to know that if I could, and she wanted, I would willingly give my life for hers.
Whenever I think of the word ‘grace’, I will think of you, Elizabeth and all your friends and loved ones who have taken this journey with you.
LikeLike
Thank you Fransi, what a huge compliment. I am grateful. love, Lucia
LikeLike
No, it’s not for us to judge who should live or die or whether one life is “better” than another. We’re all dying, from the moment we’re born. But facing death in the form of our children; well, Lucia, there’s the work, isn’t it?
Thank you, as always, for the window into the world you shared with her.
LikeLike
Yes, that’s our work. Apparently we were selected and agreed to this, and it will be a lifetime of work…sending much love and gratitude, Lucia
LikeLike
John, my grief counselor, from the beginning has asked me if I could think about Philip and I having made an agreement to come here as mother and son, that he would leave before me so that I could do the work I had to do…it’s hard to put it in words. Philip has said to me that he had to die or I wouldn’t learn what I have to learn. And it’s still my choice whether or not to learn it. As I’ve been writing my story, it’s become more and more evident that all things have led to this. Philip is trying to teach me that his death is not the grief I make it out to be; and what he means is I have to try to separate the grief from the drama. And there’s too much between us for me to think this is our first “go-round.” We’ve been together many times, in different ways.
Can’t wait to read more from you, Lucia. You are a joy.
LikeLike
Thank you Denise! I love reading your thoughts, it’s so similar to my experience and my thoughts, and yet you express it differently. Always in gratitude for our connection!
LikeLike
another teary read–I continue to be so grateful for your sharing and so admire your sense of self in this whole process. Sending much love.
LikeLike
Dear Cindi, thank you for reading. I appreciate you writing – it means a lot to know that Elizabeth’s story is touching others, maybe especially the ones who knew her… sending love, Lucia
LikeLike
How heartbreaking. It is so similar to Vic’s story. Vic’s mind was “busy” too. It is so difficult accepting Vic’s death. I am finding it more difficult by the day. It is as if the “haze” has lifted and the loss has become real. Much love dear Lucia.
LikeLike
Dear Tersia, I know just what you mean! As time moves on, in some ways it becomes even more real, though I still can’t believe it at times. I agree too, it feels at times like the clouds have moved away and I can see the reality even more as my memories get less clear and I can’t hold on to them as much as I’d like. Sending you love and blessings, Lucia
LikeLike
Lucia wrapping you in so much love & light. Sending continuous healing energy your way. You have been on my heart & in my thoughts as your first year is quickly approaching. My hand is extended. I’m here if you just need to talk about Elizabeth…cry or even smile at the many lovely foot prints she left behind in the sands of time. Sending all my love, blessings & healing energy. Take as much time to re-new as you need & take care of you right now. Xo
Jess
LikeLike
Jessica, thank you so much for reading and for sending healing energy, and for your love! I am finding this month of the one year anniversary is already very emotional, exhausting and intense, so I’m taking care of myself, trying to allow myself time to just BE. Thanks for the reminder! love and blessings, Lucia
LikeLike
Lucia, getting to know you, Elizabeth, Julianna- and the journey – touches me deeply. It is so very raw and full of our human essence, loving completely and learning to let go. My special blessings and compassion go out to Julianna as well; the sorrow of parting with a sister is heavy. How amazing that Elizabeth could be so peaceful and present, and give such a gift of sharing her understandings or experiences as she peered behind the veil. Light and love to all of you, may time continue to heal. Bev
LikeLike
Dear Bev, thank you so much for writing. You say it beautifully, it was a great gift that Elizabeth could share her presence as she moved back and forth between the worlds… Julianna, like the rest of us who loved Elizabeth, is forever changed, and in a unique way that I can’t even imagine as her mother. Thanks for your thoughtful insights. blessings and love, Lucia
LikeLike
My heart extends. I am sending a warm embrace of comfort. Belinda
LikeLike
Thank you Belinda. I am so glad you came to read and took time to write to me. many blessings, Lucia
LikeLike
Blessings to you as well. Belinda
LikeLike
Lovely warm post once again. It must be bittersweet to recall those days. Knowing they could not last forever but living in the moment.
LikeLike
Thanks Tric. It is definitely bittersweet, especially as we move closer to the first anniversary of Elizabeth’s transition, my body remembers and the tears are always close to the surface. Blessings, Lucia
LikeLike